Are Plant Based Meat Alternatives Any Healthier Than Meat?

Jim Moore • September 1, 2019

Are Highly Processed Vegan Meats a Healthy Food Choice?

Thank you for the question.

It is both an interesting and important question. Regardless of the category of diet that you enjoy to be healthy, it needs to be based on nutritionally rich, fiber dense food . A vegan diet made up of soda, potato chips, and vegan candy is not a healthy diet regardless of the fact that it does not include animal-sourced products. To place a finer point on it, I find the following guidelines for a healthy diet simple to use and effective:

No/Low P . A . S . S .

P = Processed Foods
A = Animal Products
S = Sugar
S = Salt

For me, that means Low Processed Food, No Animal Products, Low Sugar, Low Salt.

When evaluating any of the many plant-based meat substitutes they can be rated on the No/Low P . A . S . S . criteria. If the specific burger rates well it will be fine to make them part of your diet on a regular basis. If they rank poorly it is better to eat them rarely.

Please note, regardless of the plant-based alternative’s direct impact on your personal health, most will provide a more environmentally friendly choice than do the animal-based option. A cleaner, better cared for environment is healthier for everyone.

The nutritional panel from Beyond Burgers is included below:

Personally, I enjoy up to 5 Beyond Burgers per week as part of my vegan diet. I do track my daily nutrient macros and I do pay attention to my fat intake (the fat content of Beyond Burgers is high). I find the burgers delicious and when eaten as part of a mindfully tended nutritional regime, they do not have a negative impact on my health.

The original article appeared on Quora.com: https://www.quora.com/How-is-eating-a-plant-based-meat-lookalike-food-any-healthier-when-the-food-is-full-of-processed-ingredients/answer/Jim-Moore-21


Share Your Vegan Message with VeganGently.com Gear

Vegan Gently Blog

Craving a vibrant, healthy lunch that breaks the mold? Why settle for ordinary when you can build ed
By VeganGently.com Staff March 3, 2025
Craving a vibrant, healthy lunch that breaks the mold? Why settle for ordinary when you can build edible masterpieces with these innovative vegan hat sandwiches?
Bowl of diced vegetables with chop sticks
By Jim Moore February 26, 2025
So, you're thinking about going vegan? That's awesome! Whether it's for ethical reasons, environmental concerns, or personal health goals, a vegan diet can be a powerful choice. But, like any major lifestyle change, it's important to understand the potential benefits and risks. Let's explore what recent medical literature tells us.
Cozy Up with Smoky Vegan Chili
By VeganGently.com February 25, 2025
Looking for a deep, rich, soul-warming recipe for cold winter evenings? Here is your invitation to Cozy Up with Smoky Vegan Chili.
This article provides a gentle guide to help you navigate the initial stages and embrace the vegan l
By Jim Moore February 22, 2025
Embarking on a vegan journey can be an exciting and fulfilling experience. But where do you start? This article provides a gentle guide to help you navigate the initial stages and embrace the vegan lifestyle with joy and confidence.
Addressing the
By Jim Moore January 13, 2025
If lions eat meat in nature, does that mean humans should too? How can we use compassion to guide our choices?
Why do some people resist veganism, and how can we respond with empathy and logic to create meaningf
By Jim Moore January 4, 2025
Why do some people resist veganism, and how can we respond with empathy and logic to create meaningful connections?
Have you ever wondered how your dietary choices impact the environment?
By Jim Moore December 31, 2024
Have you ever wondered how your dietary choices impact the environment? Discover how veganism can drive meaningful, sustainable change worldwide.
Have you ever wondered how to discuss veganism without sparking tension? Compassionate communication
By Jim Moore December 30, 2024
Have you ever wondered how to discuss veganism without sparking tension? Compassionate communication can make all the difference.
Veganuary is here! Are you ready to simplify your meal planning while staying within budget and keep
By Jim Moore December 29, 2024
Veganuary is here! Are you ready to simplify your meal planning while staying within budget and keeping it nutritious?
Veganism is more than a diet; it’s a philosophy of compassion. Discover how kindness fosters connect
By Jim Moore December 24, 2024
Veganism is more than a diet; it’s a philosophy of compassion. Discover how kindness fosters connection and inspires lasting change.
Show More