Are Plant Based Meat Alternatives Any Healthier Than Meat?

Jim Moore • September 1, 2019

Are Highly Processed Vegan Meats a Healthy Food Choice?

Thank you for the question.

It is both an interesting and important question. Regardless of the category of diet that you enjoy to be healthy, it needs to be based on nutritionally rich, fiber dense food . A vegan diet made up of soda, potato chips, and vegan candy is not a healthy diet regardless of the fact that it does not include animal-sourced products. To place a finer point on it, I find the following guidelines for a healthy diet simple to use and effective:

No/Low P . A . S . S .

P = Processed Foods
A = Animal Products
S = Sugar
S = Salt

For me, that means Low Processed Food, No Animal Products, Low Sugar, Low Salt.

When evaluating any of the many plant-based meat substitutes they can be rated on the No/Low P . A . S . S . criteria. If the specific burger rates well it will be fine to make them part of your diet on a regular basis. If they rank poorly it is better to eat them rarely.

Please note, regardless of the plant-based alternative’s direct impact on your personal health, most will provide a more environmentally friendly choice than do the animal-based option. A cleaner, better cared for environment is healthier for everyone.

The nutritional panel from Beyond Burgers is included below:

Personally, I enjoy up to 5 Beyond Burgers per week as part of my vegan diet. I do track my daily nutrient macros and I do pay attention to my fat intake (the fat content of Beyond Burgers is high). I find the burgers delicious and when eaten as part of a mindfully tended nutritional regime, they do not have a negative impact on my health.

The original article appeared on Quora.com: https://www.quora.com/How-is-eating-a-plant-based-meat-lookalike-food-any-healthier-when-the-food-is-full-of-processed-ingredients/answer/Jim-Moore-21


Share Your Vegan Message with VeganGently.com Gear

Vegan Gently Blog

Optimized Plant Based Nutrition displayed in a kitchen
By Jim Moore July 3, 2026
Beyond the Label: Navigating the Evolution of Plant-Based Analogues and Unlocking the True Vitality of a Whole-Food Vegan Diet
Hand gently offering a pink flower to another hand
By Jim Moore June 29, 2026
Tired of the screaming matches and defensive walls that traditional advocacy can build? Discover the art of "Attractivism", a joyful, non-confrontational approach that inspires change simply by living your brightest life.
Core IngredientKitchen VersatilityRelative Food Cost ProfileLegumes (Lentils, Chickpeas, Beans)Soups
By Jim Moore June 25, 2026
Faced with tight profit margins and shifting diner preferences, restaurants need strategic menu upgrades. Discover why adding plant-based options is a highly lucrative choice.
vibrant selection of fresh vegan fruits vegetables and grains arranged on a rustic wooden table over
By Jim Moore June 23, 2026
More Than What’s on Your Plate: Shifting from a Plant-Based Diet to a Whole-Hearted Compassionate Lifestyle
Discover simple, sustainable habits to shift from junk to nourishment
By Jim Moore June 22, 2026
Stepping into plant-based living but feeling trapped by processed snacks? Discover simple, sustainable habits to shift from junk to nourishment.
A delicious array of Vegetables and vegan foods
By Jim Moore June 9, 2026
Curious about the latest trends in vegan food and drink? Discover exciting new launches, from creamy dairy-free bites to star-studded non-alcoholic sips.
A delicious array of healthy vegtables
By Jim Moore June 6, 2026
A look into new research showing that youth are highly open to meat-free diets, driven by ethics and environmental concerns.
The Plant-Based Frontier: Labeling Laws and Cultural Icons
By Jim Moore June 5, 2026
A deep dive into Europe's escalating battle over plant-based terminology alongside an exclusive look into Derrick Green's vegan legacy.
The Vegan Industry faces regulation hurdles - plate full of fruits and vegetables
By Jim Moore June 4, 2026
A breakdown of the EU's latest plant-based naming bans and rising public health concerns surrounding global industrial factory farming
Voted WNC’s Best: Get Ready for Delicious Eats, Local Shopping, and Vibrant Community Energy
By Jim Moore June 4, 2026
Want to experience Western North Carolina's top plant-based celebration? Join us at Pack Square Park for a day of food, fun, and inspiration under blue skies.
Show More